Three, two, one...
Three and two are straightforward: last Sunday, the trio of us (Brian, Guillaume, and I) headed back to the Catskills for our second foray onto the ice in as many weeks. As for one, Guillaume took his first big whipper on lead ice; haven't seen that big a fall in quite a while, and certainly not on anything as sketchy as a screw - it was quite impressive, more on it below.
With a four day cold snap this week and warmer temps forecast for the weekend, we decided to get an early start on the ice this weekend, hoping to beat the crowds and jump on relatively unhacked ice. Left the city Friday night and convened for some preparatory shenanigans in G's cabin in the Catskills: examining G's pipe collection, squeezing on a swami belt, and trying to stay warm. We bunked down later than intended, but still set the alarm for the relatively leisurely wakeup time of 6 am.
The Man in Black
Rolled in to the end of the road above Devil's Kitchen around 8, and dropped down into the gully to find it completely empty. First up was a relatively short, stepped vertical line right near the top of the gully - Stairway to Heaven (WI3-3+). Colder temps than forecast, the ice was brittle and hard and coated with a shiny sheen. Vertical climbing to a comfy ledge and small ice cave a little more than halfway, not quite big enough for me to stand in (but I kneeled for a rest). Two more short vertical sections to the typically uncomfortable Catskills topout - snow, a little frozen grass, and rock. Felt comfortable on the start of the lead, spacing screws out well, but as I got tired I slammed in more screws, which subsequently got me more tired - need to get more endurance, and a more solid lead head. B and G ran up the line quickly, and we headed down-gully to find more ice.
G spotted a great looking line: Snotsicle (WI4), a big vertical column spilling down from a overhang. It sits at the top of a steep slope, which was littered with the remains of the neighboring free-hanging column where Point and Shoot (WI5) lives. Looked intimidating, but G roped up and headed out from the right side (a steeper start than the left). Putting in a few screws, he moved up the steep start and out left to the front of the column, angling right again for a ledge in the column. A good four feet above his last screw, he popped a foot highstepping onto the ledge. I can see the details in slow-motion: the plummet sideways and down, the rope coming taught, tools flying out and down the approach slope. Afterwards, G was a foot off the ground and totally unscathed. Whew! Big fall, probably due to multiple factors, including distance above pro, rope stretch on a double line, Brian getting pulled forward, as well as a deployed screamer (nice trophy!). G was eager to head back up for revenge, but wiser heads prevailed and we headed up to downlead and pull the screws.
What was a quiet morning had turned into a zoo by this point, with multiple individual parties as well as a big guided group on TRs in lower Devil's Kitchen. We decided to head down for the two moderate pitches of Bridal Veil Falls. Easy hike down the gully, with a small rap on the kill at the base of Lower Bridal Veil - probably downclimbable, but we threw a rope. Lower Bridal Veil is short and straightforward though not overly protectable, WI2-2+ depending on conditions with a snowy topout on the frozen creek - G quickly led up to a tree, stopping to only place one screw. Upper Bridal Veil is taller, with multiple lines, easier and ledgey on the right to steeper and vertical on the left. We picked a line up the middle left (WI3?), vertical enough to get the heart rate up but stepped enough to provide good stances for sinking screws. The line we climbed headed up rightwards before trending back left to topout, with a sketchy section in the middle where cascading water ran behind a few-inch thin layer of clear, hard ice.
Dropping in to Lower Bridal Veil
The stealth belay
Good day out, especially with everyone coming out in one piece. And real good to know that the gear works as advertised (never heard the screamer deploy, despite its name). I realize we still don't have enough miles under our belts to be consistent judges of our limits, climbs that are easily within our reaches on TR and still hard on lead (we noticed that many parties stick to TR in Devil's Kitchen). Dialed it down, likely wisely, midway through the day, retreating on Snotsicle as well as saving a nice looking line by Upper Bridal Veil (Tiers of Joy WI4) for another day. Finished everything off with G's excellent mussels and fries.
More pics here and here.
8 comments:
Nice summary K. Glad we're all here to enjoy the story.
Great post about a great day! I was pretty tired the next day, I think we moved around a lot, which I actually enjoyed very much. Would like to do some alpine stuff in the future!
Are you away this weekend? May be the last of it, thinking about going up for sunday...
I'm out Sunday. Hope you guys get out another day, it's getting warm!
Some friends of mine where nearby for that fall one of you took on the Snotcicle. I'm glad no one was hurt although from the account I heard it sounds like you guys were in a bit over your heads.
Your fall was one of many very preventable falls in the Catskills this winter. Falling on ice is never a good idea and frequently leads to a fused ankle or some other even more severe trauma.
I hope you realize how lucky you were that the leader wasn't more seriously hurt. Your account doesn't seem to present the harsh reality that could have been.
Please take your time leading and TR a lot more before you jump on anything hard. The rightmost line there on the Snotcicle is more like WI5 than WI4. If you haven't seen the Dracula Fall video or Will Gadd's debrief of it now might be a good time to check that out and reconsider leading until you've cranked out a lot of mileage on a toprope.
If you have questions or need advice about leading more feel free to contact me. I'm happy to help out in any way I can.
Ryan Stefiuk
Hey Ryan,
Appreciate your input, especially as your website has been a good source of info/inspiration.
Sometimes it's good to get called out for your stupidity, and I think we all realize we were in over our heads on that climb. We knew we were lucky right after it happened, and pulled our gear to head for easier terrain. If the tone of the post seems too cavalier, my fault in the writing - we knew we messed up and got lucky.
The sobering thing is recognizing that we shouldn't have put ourselves in the spot to begin with. I - like the leader - have climbed rock for many years, but only have a few seasons of (very occasional) ice. I think of myself as a pretty conservative climber - sew things up whenever possible (trad or ice), back up raps and tie knots in the line, etc. - but that didn't keep us out of this situation, when it should have.
Thanks for the offer of help; what we need most right now is a lot more mileage on easier routes (TR or lead). We'll start next season, I guess. I've already read Will Gadd's post and the ensuing firestorm of comments, and couldn't help but think of this incident.
Kenway
Hey Ryan, thanks for the comments. I second what Kenway said, I bit more than I could chew on that one.
The Will Gadd's post was helpful in helping me think about what I need to change in my approach.
However, unlike these guys, I don't rely on chance to have a doctor on hand, one of us has that distinction :-)
Guillaume
Just glad to hear you guys made it out safe and sound. I looked at some pictures you posted and it looks like you're in the habit of placing lots of gear. That's a great start, especially in the Catskills where the ground is always a bit too nearby. Leading ice is all about being able to climb solid, while placing as much gear as you need. Running it out is only for times you're 100% certain you're not going to blow it, and even then accidents can and do happen.
I led that same line on the Snotcicle just a few days later and sewed it up too. The right side is full on WI5 and a fall just about anywhere could land you near the ground if a screw pops (always a distinct possiblity).
I suppose I'll be seeing you guys in the Catskills next winter! Have fun out there.
Post a Comment